Must Haves – Page 5 – Shop Universal

Shop New Styles Just Added on Sale – Up to 70% Off!

Save 15% on your first purchase when you sign up for our newsletter! Subscribe Now

FREE Domestic Shipping on orders totaling over $100* with code: FREESHIP100 ➔

Halloween Horror Nights 2026 Dr. Oddfellow Acrylic Set

Halloween Horror Nights 2026 Dr. Oddfellow Acrylic Set

Regular price $15.00

Regular price Sale price $15.00
Unit price per
How to Train Your Dragon Primitive Mystery Pin Set
New

How to Train Your Dragon Primitive Mystery Pin Set

Regular price $20.00

Regular price Sale price $20.00
Unit price per
Ravenclaw™ Build-A-Bag Zipper Pull
New

Ravenclaw™ Build-A-Bag Zipper Pull

Regular price $19.00

Regular price Sale price $19.00
Unit price per
Hogwarts™ Build-A-Bag Coin Pouch
New

Hogwarts™ Build-A-Bag Coin Pouch

Regular price $35.00

Regular price Sale price $35.00
Unit price per
Slytherin™ Build-A-Bag Zipper Pull
New

Slytherin™ Build-A-Bag Zipper Pull

Regular price $19.00

Regular price Sale price $19.00
Unit price per
Yellow Luma™ Shoulder Pal
New

Yellow Luma™ Shoulder Pal

Regular price $40.00

Regular price Sale price $40.00
Unit price per
Slytherin™ Build-A-Bag Charm
New

Slytherin™ Build-A-Bag Charm

Regular price $19.00

Regular price Sale price $19.00
Unit price per
Gryffindor™ Build-A-Bag Coin Pouch
New

Gryffindor™ Build-A-Bag Coin Pouch

Regular price $35.00

Regular price Sale price $35.00
Unit price per
Sorting Hat™ Build-A-Bag Coin Pouch
New

Sorting Hat™ Build-A-Bag Coin Pouch

Regular price $35.00

Regular price Sale price $35.00
Unit price per
Halloween Horror Nights 2026 Hellraiser Poster

Halloween Horror Nights 2026 Hellraiser Poster

Regular price $20.00

Regular price Sale price $20.00
Unit price per
Universal Epic Universe How to Train Your Dragon Vinyl Record
New

Universal Epic Universe How to Train Your Dragon Vinyl Record

Regular price $45.00

Regular price Sale price $45.00
Unit price per
Second Generation Interactive Wand - Harry Potter

Second Generation Interactive Wand - Harry Potter

Regular price $85.00

Regular price Sale price $85.00
Unit price per
Minions & Monsters Blind Box
New

Minions & Monsters Blind Box

Regular price $20.00

Regular price Sale price $20.00
Unit price per
Hufflepuff™ Build-A-Bag Coin Pouch
New

Hufflepuff™ Build-A-Bag Coin Pouch

Regular price $35.00

Regular price Sale price $35.00
Unit price per
Halloween Horror Nights 2026 Fortnitemares Sticker Set

Halloween Horror Nights 2026 Fortnitemares Sticker Set

Regular price $16.00

Regular price Sale price $16.00
Unit price per
Universal Epic Universe Dark Universe Vinyl Record
New

Universal Epic Universe Dark Universe Vinyl Record

Regular price $50.00

Regular price Sale price $50.00
Unit price per
Blue Luma™ Shoulder Pal
New

Blue Luma™ Shoulder Pal

Regular price $40.00

Regular price Sale price $40.00
Unit price per
Halloween Horror Nights 2026 Stranger Things 5 Spirit Jersey
New

Halloween Horror Nights 2026 Stranger Things 5 Spirit Jersey

Regular price $85.00

Regular price Sale price $85.00
Unit price per
Halloween Horror Nights 2026 Women’s Crop Top Featuring Jack the Clown and Dr. Oddfellow

Halloween Horror Nights 2026 Women’s Crop Top Featuring Jack the Clown and Dr. Oddfellow

Regular price $32.00

Regular price Sale price $32.00
Unit price per
Halloween Horror Nights 2026 Evil Dead Burn T-Shirt
New

Halloween Horror Nights 2026 Evil Dead Burn T-Shirt

Regular price $30.00

Regular price Sale price $30.00
Unit price per
Halloween Horror Nights 2026 Stranger Things Season 5 Mug
New

Halloween Horror Nights 2026 Stranger Things Season 5 Mug

Regular price $20.00

Regular price Sale price $20.00
Unit price per
Halloween Horror Nights 2026 Ozzy Osbourne Crewneck Fleece
Coming soon

Halloween Horror Nights 2026 Ozzy Osbourne Crewneck Fleece

Regular price $65.00

Regular price Sale price $65.00
Unit price per
Ravenclaw™ Build-A-Bag Coin Pouch
New

Ravenclaw™ Build-A-Bag Coin Pouch

Regular price $35.00

Regular price Sale price $35.00
Unit price per
Dark Universe Darkmoor Mystery Pin Set
New

Dark Universe Darkmoor Mystery Pin Set

Regular price $20.00

Regular price Sale price $20.00
Unit price per